Relating to conserving tabs on our beloved furry companions, the expertise accessible to pet homeowners has considerably progressed through the years. Canine GPS collars, such because the Fi Collection 3 and Halo Collar 3, have risen to prominence as dependable instruments to make sure pets’ security and supply peace of thoughts to pet dad and mom in every single place. However a sensible collar isn’t nearly monitoring your pet’s location; in addition they supply insights into your canine’s well being and exercise ranges.
With distinct options and capabilities, each Fi Collection 3 and Halo Collar 3 stand out within the pet tech market the place there are tonnes of GPS canine trackers. However how do they stack up towards one another? Which one will higher serve your wants, and extra importantly, your pet’s wants? On this detailed comparability of those two superior GPS collar, we are going to delve into their functionalities, applied sciences, sturdiness, buyer evaluations, compatibility, and buyer help, providing complete perception that will help you make an knowledgeable selection.
From superior location expertise to sturdiness and battery life, to extra integrations and help, we dissect the important options of each these collars to find out which could emerge as the higher possibility. Let’s get began on our comparative journey between the superior Fi Collection 3 and the modern Halo Collar 3 and see which is actually higher for canine homeowners.
Fi Vs Halo
Full evaluations: Halo Collar Assessment • Fi Canine Collar Assessment
(Notice: The Halo collar is a shock collar – it’s been cleverly marketed, however it’s completely a shock collar, and also you do have to know that, these should not coaching strategies I condone, however in some very slim situations the good canine fence of the halo collar is a bonus)
Full Comparability: Fi Collection 3 and Halo Collar 3
Each gadgets supply the advantages of good expertise, a monitoring function, and the power to incorporate members of the family, however there are some issues that differ between them – and we’ll be digging into these options right here so you understand which is an efficient selection for you and your pup.
Battery Life
Relating to battery life, how a lot time does it take earlier than it’s essential cost them? Each the Fi Collection 3 and Halo Collar 3 have totally different capabilities and efficiency ranges that set them aside.
Fi Collection 3 boasts a powerful battery life primarily based on its utilization mode. Within the default setting, its battery can last as long as 3 months on a single cost – nonetheless – in practicality, now we have an acre of land that’s somewhat effectively coated with wifi (which helps the Fi Collection 3 additionally), and as a substitute of the three months, we get a few month – much less when there’s a storm or a big powercut.
Halo Collar 3, needs to be charged every single day. It has a 24hr battery life at most, however it does supply a extra energy heavy system. Virtually, this can be a ache within the butt and it does imply that it’s a must to keep on high of this.
Superior Expertise and Options
The Fi Collection 3 brings some highly effective tech advantages. It makes use of a triple menace of worldwide satellite tv for pc positioning programs: GPS, GLONASS, and Galileo, able to finding your canine inside a mere 6-foot radius. All these are coupled with the long-range, low-power LTE-M mobile community extending about 30% additional than conventional mobile networks, additional reinforcing the gadget’s huge connectivity vary – which is even buffed by your wi-fi connection (we love our mesh community for this!).
Comparatively, the Halo Canine Collar takes a extra singular method with its PrecisionGPS™ system, successfully studying your canine’s habits and actions to boost monitoring accuracy progressively. Furthermore, Halo 3 employs an lively antenna engagement mechanism that proves helpful in difficult places with poor satellite tv for pc reception.
Escape Detection and Swift Alerts
Each Fi Collection 3 and Halo Collar 3 lay substantial emphasis on fast escape detection and escape alerts – and that’s what most good canine collars do – however these two are in all probability the perfect of their relative sectors.
The Fi Collection 3 employs proprietary algorithms that swiftly alert the pet proprietor when their canine escapes, making certain a fast restoration course of. This makes the Fi Collection 3 notably helpful for canine vulnerable to adventurous escapades and anxious pets vulnerable to working off in shock or fright.
The Halo Collar 3, whereas devoted to flee detection, enhances its utility with real-time location monitoring. Not solely does it detect escapes promptly, however it might additionally repeatedly and precisely monitor your pet’s actions. The actual-time monitoring system of Halo 3 is very useful in case your pet is repeatedly on the transfer or interacts with a number of canine, serving to preserve tabs on their general motion and exercise ranges.
Sturdiness and Resilience
When contemplating sturdiness of the gadget, Fi Collection 3 appears to have an edge. With a powerful waterproof ranking of IP68 and IP66K (that means it’s fully dust-tight and may survive as much as 1.5 meters of recent water for as much as half-hour with out the necessity for further instances or covers) it showcases elevated resilience to each water and excessive strain. Furthermore, Fi Collection 3 ensures your pet’s security with its stainless-steel physique proof against punctures, which, while ours has worn considerably because it’s preliminary use in December 2022, it’s holding up actually effectively.
Whereas the Halo Collar 3 does promise a water-resistant design, it lacks a disclosed waterproof ranking and doesn’t boast particular destruction-proof options, placing it barely behind Fi Collection 3 – I additionally actually don’t like the duvet – it makes issues much more fussy – which contemplating it’s the perfect a part of $700, and I’ve to cost it each day? It’s not one of the best ways to maintain issues easy.
Boundaries: Geofence vs Digital Fence
Each collars present the power to arrange boundaries or a “designated space” – each use your canine location vs the strains and limits you set inside their app – nonetheless the consequence of your canine going via that digital boundary is considerably totally different.
Fi Collar gives a multi-point fenced space now, permitting you to map out your precise plot and set it as a protected zone and use GPS expertise to put our furry mates inside that boundary – nonetheless – the consequence of your pup leaving this zone is to easily warn you that pup has performed so. Which is admittedly useful for us in our house and {couples} very well with our bodily fence.
In the meantime, Halo Collar 3 gives a “good fence”, and is extra akin to an invisible fence, i.e. there’s a punitive measure in your canine in the event that they violate the halo fences.
While I’ve but to see it occur with the Halo collar, I do know GPS gadgets should not infallible (I imply, how typically are you driving and it pings you onto a unique highway and calls for you do a u-turn?), and if that type of error occurs to your canine? That might lead to a redirected chunk… That provides me pause.
Wearability
It’s good to notice that the Halo collar shouldn’t be a collar that’s designed for fixed put on. It’s a collar that’s not meant to go in a crate, not meant to be worn within the house, however is supposed to be worn out of the home in your yard or a social space.
That is in complete opposition to the Fi Collection 3 collar which is designed to be worn all day lengthy and that’s a very highly effective factor to recollect when making your resolution.
Exercise Monitoring and Well being Monitoring
The Fi Collection 3 collar not solely tracks your canine’s location but additionally is an exercise tracker and sleep (which is my absolute favorite) – Measuring exercise ranges by measuring steps taken all through the day and it’s all seen within the fi app, which has improved considerably through the years. This function permits pet homeowners to observe their canine’s general well being by setting step targets and figuring out developments that have an effect on their well-being.
Whereas the Halo collar app primarily focuses on superior location monitoring, and while it does monitor exercise, the halo app isn’t as natural because the Fi app – at the very least for me.
Positive, let’s delve even deeper, understanding how every tracker suits into the broader ecosystem of pet care and administration instruments, compatibility with different gadgets, and buyer help from every firm.
Integrations and Compatibility
In in the present day’s related world, the power to share information and combine with different administration instruments will be extremely helpful. It permits extra seamless pet supervision and extra helpful information consolidation.
Fi Collection 3 operates in a closed ecosystem. The collar’s information will be accessed through their proprietary Fi cellular app on Android and iOS, which permits for real-time location monitoring, exercise monitoring, and geofence setup. As of now, it seems Fi Collection 3 doesn’t readily combine with different pet monitoring apps or gadgets past its personal choices.
However, Halo Collar 3 gives extra complete integrations with its partnerships with main pet care platforms. Its sturdy emphasis on constructing an holistic pet care system is clear from partnerships with canine coaching consultants like Cesar Millan. As such, the Halo system caters not solely to security however behavioral coaching too.
Leash Attachment
This one may very well make an enormous distinction for lots of you, and it’s an oversight for lots of people
The Halo 3 Collar can’t have a leash hooked up to it as it’s a shock collar.
The Fi Collection 3 not solely can have a leash hooked up to it, however it truly has a break power of up 400lbs – which is fairly good! You can too elect to improve the collar to a good sturdier collar like we did for Shelby from Tactipup! We’re actually happy with it, it’s good to have one thing a bit extra vibrant however nonetheless very easy to make use of.
Buyer Service and Assist
Each firms present sturdy customer support, and having examined each, they’re fairly equal.
Fi gives:
- A dwell chat function on their web site for quick help.
- A web based useful resource heart with FAQ and troubleshooting information.
- E mail help for extra complicated queries.
Halo gives:
- E mail and telephone help, addressing assorted person wants.
- Intensive assets of their digital coaching heart geared up with video classes and solutions to widespread FAQs.
- Stay chat function on the web site for real-time help – which I do actually like – however as at all times they’ve somewhat restricted capabilities.
Price & Subscriptions
Halo has a sizeable upfront price of $699, and Fi truly works in a way more related option to your telephone plan, so there’s a $20 activation, after which simply the month-to-month price.
Each trackers require subscription plans to entry full-featured companies.
For the Fi Collection 3, relying on how typically you need to pay, will rely upon how a lot you pay, the subscription plan is kind of affordable in my view.
Activiation (up entrance) – $20
Month-to-month – $24
Each 6 months – $102
Yearly – $192
Each 2 years – $336
Fi additionally present a multi-dog low cost of 5% and waive the long run activation price.
For the Halo Collar 3, the upfront price is a whopping $699, plus a month-to-month price of someplace between $5.99 for the essential plan and $29.99 for the extra superior plan that has extra information storage for what your GPS canine collar truly learns about your canine.
Halo additionally present a multi-dog low cost additionally, their high two plans give a $50 low cost on the gadget, and are a further $4-5/month.
Honey!
For those who’re on the lookout for reductions? At all times go to Honey. You’d be amazed what number of codes they’ve (and I examined it for each websites, they do normally have codes working!). The financial savings fluctuate and is probably not main – however Honey can completely make it easier to make these pennies go even additional!
Wrapping it Up
By a complete comparability between the Fi Collection 3 and Halo Collar 3, now we have explored their superior expertise, design, and capabilities that will help you select probably the most appropriate collar for your loved one canine companion.
The Fi Collection 3 is an outstanding possibility for nearly each canine mum or dad, providing an intensive community protection, spectacular battery life, and sturdy sturdiness. With the added bonus of monitoring well being and exercise information, it is a wonderful funding to make sure the security and well-being of your pet.
However, the Halo Collar 3 caters to a distinct segment market with its different to an invisible fence which might be completely customisable out of your telephone… proving to be a beneficial device for many who can’t fence their yard or lack entry to a safe space. It’s a wi-fi fence with monitoring options designed to present on the spot suggestions to you and your canine that they’re going the place they shouldn’t. This permits pet homeowners to create digital boundaries that safeguard their pets and guarantee individualized monitoring, even in probably the most complicated environments.
Finally, each collars show a dedication to pet security and dependable monitoring. Nevertheless, the Fi Collection 3 is the true selection in case you’re simply trying to preserve monitor of your canine, and have that further peace of thoughts, and is a flexible selection appropriate for a broader vary of canine dad and mom, whereas the Halo Collar 3 caters to the distinctive wants of these in quest of a neater or extra versatile fencing resolution.
Personally? We’ll be utilizing the Fi everyday, and we don’t have a lot of a motive to proceed utilizing the Halo collar. Which is a disgrace, however, that’s the way it goes!
Writer, Ali Smith
Ali Smith is the Optimistic Pet Professional, canine coach and is the founding father of Rebarkable. She is keen about serving to pet dad and mom get issues proper, proper from the beginning. To assist create a pet able to being a assured and adaptable member of the family and preserve puppies out of shelters.
Ali has received a number of awards for her canine coaching, and has had her weblog (this weblog!) rated as 2021 & 2022 worlds’ greatest pet weblog!
Due to depositphotos.com for the photographs!
